Deadly Seeds of "False Dichotomy"

Greetings!

Here is an anecdote that made me think about an insidious infliction that affects humanity.

A 'normal' shepherd is chatting with an 'educated' shepherd. Let's call them Norm and Ed.

Norm: How many sheep do you have?
Ed: White or Black?
Norm: White?
Ed: 50. By the way I have 50 Black sheep too. Wonder what you have against the Black sheep?
Norm: But I asked about all the sheep?
Ed: Oh! Did you? You just said, "White?"

Norm: Hey Buddy, I don't have anything against any of the sheep. By the way, do you get enough wool ?
Ed: From which one? White or Black?
Norm: Black? (Thinking he won't repeat the mistake this time!)
Ed: Well I get enough from Black ones. By the way I get enough from white ones too. Wonder why are you bent on exploiting the Black sheep for their wool?

Norm: (Gives up)

Black Sheep and White Sheep

I call Ed's infliction as "False Dichotomy". This has been a cognitive conditioning for gullible ones, usually perpetuated by those with ulterior motives. This conditioning causes a person to divide everything they perceive in (usually) two categories. Then the person uses this division to associate all that is wrong in the world to one of these. 

This also is a major hindrance to learning and impediment in one's evolution as a human being. The moment one starts seeing things in such falsely dichotomous manner, one stops seeing the truth and crux of the matter. 

Each time one faces such a false dichotomous view, it sows a seed of doubt in mind. I think it is extremely important to chuck out such bad seeds from mind and not nurture them as the fruits of such an endeavor are poisonous for one and all. "False Dichotomy" is probably one of the major causes of 'human-created' problems that society has faced over millennia. I think a lot of problems faced by humanity today can be traced to this infliction.

Brown, Black, White, or Grey,
They jus' eat grass, an' sometimes bray,
Seeds of doubt sow poison, an' lead us astray, 
False Dichotomy! jus' keep-it-at-bay!!   

Sincerely Mine!
Anand Kulkarni

Comments

Pawan said…
Another thing I can add to this vein is “labelism”. Typical social and political narratives are centered around assigning reductive labels to complex things that cannot be easily argued on one side or the other.

I think it is human nature to “over”-simplify things so as to not have to spend time thinking the next time around. And out of this can come the blindspots - one of which as you mentioned is the False Dichotomy.
Thursday, May 14, 2020
Ken Montgomery said…
This is a great post and something I've been thinking about a lot lately, especially as people want to argue against facts and science as we better understand what not to do in response to Covid... There is an old saying in law "If you have the fact, argue the facts... if you don't have the facts, pound the table...." We see a lot of that today and I agree, you have to not let those people derail you... don't give then your attention because they succeed when they get you to expend energy on them.
Thursday, May 14, 2020
Anand P Kulkarni said…
Agree with you Pavan. Reductionism is a great scientific tool but lousy social tenet.
Thursday, May 14, 2020
Anand P Kulkarni said…
You are rght Ken,

This is unfortunate but has been happening. Number of societies in world fell for these tendencies, especially when such pounding was incessant.

On individual level it is best to ignore. However I beleive that as a society, the wise ones, especially those who have influence on young minds, should guide them to not fall for such cognitive biases.
Thursday, May 14, 2020
Anonymous said…
Very true, Many great personalities especially, the saints see the things, the world as it is and that's why understand the root causes and power behind each happening and saying correctly. Good one. Thanks!
Saturday, May 16, 2020
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The envelope

Image
Greetings! "Do I look like a beggar to you?" bellowed the Sir. The bewildered boy was at a loss of words. He started trembling and I thought he may fall down. "No... Sir..." He managed to mutter while clutching the tuition fee money in his hand. The Sir had an imposing personality and commanding voice. Getting a seat at his tuition was considered to be a one way ticket to get into the "meritorious students club". He used to nudge, cajole, incite and drive students towards fending off and getting victory over those nightmarish adversaries of every middle school child. The deadly trio of Audacious Algebra, Gigantic Geometry and Sneaky Science. It was the first day of this boy in this prestigious tuition class. (And mine too). He was facing the wrath of Sir as he went to pay the fee with currency notes in his hand. The boy looked at the ground as if he desperately wished the earth to swallow him. He felt the glowering gaze of Sir in front and t
Read more

Staging Sagely

Image
Greetings! In rocketry, "staging" means mounting multiple separable parts (with their own engines and propellants) to create a multistage rocket. These stages might be in tandem (that is one above other) or in parallel to each other. The most popular is a 2-stage rocket but there could be 5 (or even more) stages.  For a rocket, the ultimate aim is to put the payload in orbit. Each of the stage plays it's part in giving it the right speed and proper height. These parts do their "part" (literally), and then usually get jettisoned away, with explosive bolts. The rocket launch is successful, when each of these stages fire up, burn out, remain attached, as well as get detached, in the right place and at the right time (which is usually not a moment before nor a moment after they are supposed to do so) You may say, this is all good, but why write a blog on it? Well, because i think this entire process maps to life and growth as each one of us experiences it. As we gro
Read more

The unscathed frog metaphor

Image
Greetings! One thing common among Zoologists and Management Gurus (and perhaps the rare amphibian-cuisine-connoisseurs) is their fascination with the boiled frog! So, what is this oft-repeated sordid tale of the poor and ultimately scathed amphibian?  The pop version goes as follows -  "A frog is let into a pot with water. It makes itself comfy and takes to it like a fish (or rather like a frog) in water. Then the pot is very slowly heated. The frog ignores this slow, gradual, incremental change. But then, at one point of time, the water starts boiling and it is too late for the frog to get out of situation. The frog gets boiled eventually." Morale of this pop version of story is clear - beware of slow, gradual, incremental changes. Watch out for tell-tale signs, lest the situation worsens to the doomsday scenario.  They even have a name for this condition where people, organizations and societies go on ignoring gradual change and then eventually face their doom on account of
Read more

Rescuing the Romeo

Image
Greetings! Everyone (well, at least everyone who knows a little about English Literature), knows the plot of a play named 'Romeo and Juliet', written by that gifted prolific playwright - William Shakespeare.  It is a tragedy that has been played on stage for centuries and adapted into most of the languages. This tale has inspired countless adaptations, musicals and movies.  It has also been analyzed, critiqued and discussed over perhaps millions of conversations.  Still, as is the case with such timeless tales, once in a while someone sees one or more dimensions of this story and cannot help sharing what has been glimpsed. (Now, that I have given justification of writing once more about this oft written about tale - let me get on with it ..)  So, in the dimension that I glimpsed, I see Romeo as the intelligent, idealistic but impulsive and immature force of passion that lies within all of us. Romeo is the part within us that climbs the walls, jumps the balconies and goes to ext
Read more

Predestined "Free Will"

Image
Greetings! Question is, "Is all that happens predestined? Or human beings have free will to chose?" A boy throws a stone. Does he chose to throw it or the strong thought to throw germinates due to a program in subconscious driven by nature, nurture and circumstances (including gut bacteria)? Most experiments say that the latter is true. The decision already happens and then the thought comes in to merely justify it. Read a very interesting compilation of such experiments Here . Imagine a magic(?) trick where cards written A, B, C are put in front of a person . They are face up. The person is told that she has free will to pick any. The person choses A. The magician says that your free will was already predetermined - he takes a sealed envelope from his coat pocket. She opens the envelope and it says 'You are predestined to chose option A '.... The person is shocked and awed to see that her free will choice was predestined!!! (Of course, if she chose B then
Read more